The Argument for Small Data: How Hotels Can Use Their Data Today

May 2, 2016 David Turnbull

argument_for_small_data_how_hotels_can_use_their_data_today.jpg

If ever there was a Zeitgeist phrase to typify the seismic changes occurring within the hotel industry, “demand management” is the one I associate most with hotels today. The industry finds itself at a crossroads where the blurred lines of responsibility for commercial development are failing to launch, with new directions in structures, technology and processes are the missing ingredients. Financial stakeholders are demanding increased attention to profit conversion, attributed to the dominance of Online Travel Agents (OTAs) and the slipping control of distribution costs.

New Call-to-actionAlthough there are multiple definitions for demand management in hotels, it should be viewed as a holistic merger of the disciplines of revenue management, distribution, sales and marketing, and finance, adopting an integrated approach to organizational structure, standards, and processes.

Due to the lead-time involved to effectively implement a more hollistic management culture, my belief is that hotel organizations should ignore the hype surrounding the potential of “big data” and focus now on developing integrated strategy and decision-making through intelligent and achievable “small data” tactics.  




Historical Perspectives

The challenge the industry faces is the historical structures influencing the current management of demand. Hotels maintain outdated approaches to segmentation, where traditional market structures dominate strategy and forecast environments, without sufficient (if any) cross-reference to the channel of demand.

Revenue management systems continue to espouse competent total revenue generation via price and stay pattern optimization, but they do so without any direct consideration of cost of distribution and direct and third-party marketing investments. 

Significantly, the historical dominance of brick-and-mortar agencies provided stable and regimented B2B demand for hotels, replaced in recent years by a resurgent OTA market, which has encouraged a new, highly unstable transient segment of B2C consumers, with changing priorities and approaches to travel consumption.

 Read our guide to Hotel Data and Analytics.

Current Inertia

The reality today is that the selling of a hotel room has become so complex that the current organizational structures, operating standards, and processes are insufficient to satisfy “the new normal.”

Despite industry-wide agreement that cost of distribution is one the largest threats to future profit generation, hotel organizations are slow to adopt channel segmentation and cost optimization within their forecasting environments.

The reason for this is clearly attributed to historic approaches to budget, strategy, and forecast management, compounded by challenges in the collection, storage, extraction and analysis of relevant data within hotels’ operational databases.

Whilst this is one obvious example of the inherent challenges the industry faces, I also see the following points as critical towards the current malaise:

  • Disjointed commercial organizational structures with inconsistent forward planning and reporting tools

  • High labor cost and time management associated with channel optimization and inventory management

  • Reactive and long-lead approach to cost of distribution calculations

  • Inaccurate net contribution due to an inward focus on commission spend and an absence of all relevant investments attributed to cost of distribution

  • Low understanding of the tactics involved and the positive impact gained, from position optimization via OTAs to increase direct conversion (billboard impact)

  • Static market and pricing intelligence tools with limited opportunity for dynamic demand-based competitor sets

demand_management_cycle.jpg

The First Steps: Small Data

The long-term aim should be to merge key elements of revenue management, distribution, sales & marketing, and finance, and implement a cultural, technological and structural approach known as demand management.

The result will lead to a significant harmonization of key responsibilities, integrated planning and execution of demand management activities, satisfied “on-target” customers, and a focus on profit optimization.

In the short term, there are many small data solutions available to incubate the above opportunities. By small data, I mean the effective management and analysis of existing indicators of demand in a structured and progressional approach.

Below are some examples I see as small data opportunities that hotel organizations should consider implementing over the next 12 months:

Demand Segmentation: Countering the analytical limitations of individual “silos” of market and channel segment data, hotels should adapt their segmentation strategy (and forward planning) and set up unique demand segments, which merge specific market and channel segments into relevant buckets of demand. 

Net Contribution Forecasting Environment: The next step for hotels is to adapt their forecasting environment to proactively calculate and include the historic total cost of distribution, and forecast future assumptions per demand segment, enabling net contribution visualization.

User and Third-Party Data Tracking: Whilst booking pace and pick-up trend analysis is commonplace, there are many additional user-generated and third-party analytics available to hotels that not collectively tracked within the forecast environment for progressional trends and analysis during the active forecast/booking window.

Profit What-if Scenarios: By adopting the above sequence of recommendations, a hotel now has the potential within its revised forecasting environment to commence the testing of “what-if scenarios” based on alternate combinations of demand mix, volumes, positioning and pricing, to determine the optimal strategy to maximize net contribution and profit generation.

 

The Journey Ahead

If I can be critical of the outlined future path to more hollistic hotel management, it is that whilst there are already significant advancements in the automation and integration of demand channels and strategy, the reality is that the collection, storage, extraction, and analysis of even “small data” remain a great challenge to implement.

The cultural shift towards integrated planning, decision making and progressional management of demand requires significant commitment of any hotel organization to achieve, along with the collective support of the numerous operational and intelligence technology vendors.

What I do expect, however, is that in the coming years we will start to see the evolution of the first wave of “Demand Managers,” educated and supported to achieve the obvious requirements for maximum profit optimization– Demand Management is on the rise!

This article was orginally featured in the HOTEL Yearbook 2014. 

New Call-to-action